Holiday white elephant gift exchanges are always fun—until it’s time to pick out a gift, and your mind draws a blank. What’s the perfect blend of hilarious and creative, yet still worth fighting over? Luckily, we’ve got you covered. Below, you’ll find 15 of the best gag gifts to surprise, delight, and even confuse your party-goers.
These unique and funny ideas—from practical to downright absurd—are all vouched for by reviewers who’ve seen their success at white elephant gatherings. Spoiler alert: these gifts are so good they often get stolen multiple times. Mission accomplished.
Disclaimer: This article does not contain any affiliate links. All product links are provided solely for your convenience and do not generate any commission or revenue for the author or publisher.
1. A Mini Screaming Goat Everyone Will Fight Over
This bestselling Screaming Goat figure isn’t just a toy—it’s an iconic stress reliever. When pressed, it emits a shriek that perfectly captures the chaos of life, making it the perfect conversation starter. With over 31,000 five-star reviews, it’s a white elephant MVP.
“I wanted something totally random for a party… This screaming goat was absolutely perfect! It became the white elephant gift everyone wanted,” shared one Amazon reviewer.
📍 Where to buy: Mini Screaming Goat at Amazon ($8)
🎄 Festive option: Christmas version at Amazon ($9)
2. Soap That Looks Like Hot Wings and Celery
Don’t be fooled—this isn’t food. These hyper-realistic soap bars mimic hot wings, celery, and even blue cheese dressing. Be sure to clarify they’re not edible before someone takes a bite!
📍 Where to buy: Hot Wings Soap at Etsy ($20)
3. A Lego-Compatible Mug
Lego enthusiasts, rejoice! This BPA-free mug is not only functional but allows you to attach toy bricks for endless customization. It’s a quirky choice sure to capture the hearts of nostalgic builders.
“It was for a white elephant and was traded a few times. Lego fans liked it!” said one Amazon reviewer.
📍 Where to buy: Lego-Compatible Mug at Amazon ($12)
4. A Hands-Free Neck Fan
This gift is as practical as it is unexpected. Perfect for anyone prone to overheating, this rechargeable fan can be worn around the neck, delivering hands-free cooling.
📍 Where to buy: Hands-Free Neck Fan at Amazon ($17)
5. Light-Up Lightsaber Chopsticks
Nothing says “fight for your white elephant gift” quite like these glowing Star Wars-inspired chopsticks. They’re functional, BPA-free, and powered by included batteries for instant use.
“We went to a white elephant gift exchange… People were fighting over them so much,” raved a reviewer.
📍 Where to buy: Lightsaber Chopsticks at Amazon ($13)
6. A “National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation” Puzzle
Relive the hilarity of the Griswold family Christmas with this 300-piece puzzle. It’s a festive activity everyone can enjoy—just add the movie for extra holiday vibes.
📍 Where to buy: Christmas Vacation Puzzle at Walmart ($10)
7. A “Real Housewives of Salt Lake City” Heather Ornament
Fans of the Real Housewives franchise will love this ornament featuring Heather’s epic mic-drop moment. It’s a surefire way to get a laugh from Bravo superfans.
📍 Where to buy: Heather Ornament at Etsy ($13)
8. A Silly Yet Useful Neck Light
Though it may look goofy, this hands-free light is actually a practical tool for reading, crafting, or camping. Its Inspector Gadget vibe makes it a fun yet functional gag gift.
📍 Where to buy: Neck Light at Amazon ($22)
9. An Adult Coloring Book for Stress Relief
Nothing says catharsis like coloring snarky phrases like, “Who left the bag of idiots open?” This adult coloring book is hilarious and therapeutic—perfect for the creatively stressed.
📍 Where to buy: Adult Coloring Book at Amazon ($8)
10. Car Dip Clips for Drive-Thru Enthusiasts
These “dip clips” attach to car vents, ensuring sauce lovers never have to go nugget-dry again. Be prepared for this to be the most fought-over gift at the party.
📍 Where to buy: Dip Clips at Amazon ($10)
11. A Reusable Greek-Style Coffee Cup
Modeled after NYC’s iconic diner paper cup, this ceramic tumbler is both stylish and functional. Dishwasher- and microwave-safe, it’s ideal for coffee lovers with a sense of humor.
📍 Where to buy: Greek-Style Coffee Cup at Amazon ($17)
12. A Literal Mini White Elephant Planter
This ceramic planter takes the white elephant theme to a dad-joke level. Add a small succulent for extra charm.
📍 Where to buy: Mini White Elephant Planter at Amazon ($10)
13. A Mojo Dojo Casa House Candle
Inspired by the Barbie movie phenomenon, this Kenough candle smells like rich mahogany, spices, and vanilla. Perfect for anyone who’s still quoting the movie.
📍 Where to buy: Mojo Dojo Casa House Candle at Etsy ($23)
14. Shakespeare’s Best Insults Calendar
Start 2025 with a bang—of witty Shakespearean burns, that is. This daily desk calendar is perfect for literature lovers and anyone in need of an Elizabethan comeback.
📍 Where to buy: Shakespeare Insults Calendar at Amazon ($16)
15. A Prank Pack Gift Box
Make your white elephant contribution extra memorable with this prank gift box. Disguise your actual gift in packaging for fake products like a cat hat or pet butler vest.
“The person who got it totally believed it was a real product… Another co-worker stole it, only to be disappointed it wasn’t real,” shared one delighted reviewer.
📍 Where to buy: Prank Gift Box at Amazon ($10)
Whether you go for something useful, absurd, or laugh-out-loud funny, these gag gifts are sure to bring life to any white elephant exchange. So go ahead—pick your favorite and prepare for the laughs.
Also Read: Holiday Countdown Your MKE Community Journal’s Tips for Smart Shopping: How to Navigate Holiday Deals